Unauthorized Overtime: Why It Happens and How to Prevent It

creative shot of clock with employee hands working on laptop in the background

In this guide we explore the concept of unauthorized overtime; why it happens, and how it can be prevented while uncovering ways companies can prevent unwanted costs and ensure they are in line with labor laws.

What is unauthorized overtime?

When employees work beyond their regular hours, they might be entitled to extra pay known as "overtime pay". However, not all overtime hours are created equal. Unauthorized overtime happens when an employee works extra hours without getting the go-ahead from their managers or supervisors.

In contrast, authorized overtime is when an employee gets a green signal to work beyond their regular work schedule and is typically eligible for overtime pay as defined by the Fair Labor Standards Act or the state labor department.

When is a worker legally entitled to overtime?

Overtime laws are designed to protect workers, ensuring they receive fair compensation for extended work hours. According to federal guidelines, any non-exempt worker clocking in over 40 hours during a single workweek is entitled to overtime pay.

But who exactly qualifies as a non-exempt worker? Two primary criteria need to be met:

  1. Earnings: Regardless of being hourly or salaried, if an individual's earnings are below $684 weekly or $35,568 annually, they fall into the non-exempt category.

  2. Type of job duties: The nature of an employee's tasks also matters. Even if they meet the salary criteria, their profession must not be among those classified as exempt.

Interestingly, there's no cap on the number of overtime hours a person can clock in a week under federal provisions. Be it 45, 60, or even 80 hours, employers are legally obligated to compensate for the extra time.

Reasons why unauthorized overtime occurs

1. Management issues

Often, unauthorized overtime occurs because there's a gap in management. Without proper supervision, employees might work overtime without approval. It's not just about keeping an eye on employee hours; it's also about clear communication.

If managers and supervisors don't make overtime policies crystal clear, it's easy for misunderstandings to happen. Both paying unauthorized overtime and working unauthorized overtime can become frequent issues.

2. Employee factors

Employees might sometimes think it's okay to work overtime without getting the nod. Maybe they don't fully grasp the company's unauthorized overtime policy or overtime laws in general. Sometimes, personal financial needs push them to log those extra hours, hoping to earn more.

Then there's the work culture. If a company often praises those burning the midnight oil, even if it prohibits unauthorized overtime, employees might feel the need to work extra just to fit in.

3. Organizational structure and processes

At times, the very way a business operates can lead to unauthorized overtime. For example, if there are inefficient workflows, employees might find themselves working overtime just to complete their tasks. A lack of essential tools or resources can also push employees into this zone.

If a company isn't aware of its own overtime laws or doesn't have a system in place to track hours worked, unauthorized overtime can easily slip through the cracks.

Useful Read: Choosing the Right Organizational Structure: Pros and Cons Explored

The impact of unauthorized overtime

When employees clock in more hours than what's allowed or approved, the repercussions are not just limited to those extra hours. Unauthorized overtime has a domino effect that ripples through various aspects of a business.

1. Financial strain

It's not just about the direct cost, though that's a significant factor. When employees work unauthorized overtime, the company has to pay overtime wages, which can quickly add up. But that's not the only concern.

If businesses don't pay employees according to federal law or regulations set by the state labor department, they can face hefty penalties.

These penalties are in addition to the overtime wages they must pay to eligible employees. Thus, the financial burden of unauthorized overtime can be twofold: the increased wages and potential legal penalties.

2. Employee well-being

Prolonged periods of overtime work, especially when it's not approved, can take a toll on employees. They might feel burned out, leading to increased stress levels. Over time, this can result in a dip in overall productivity.

While in the short term, it might seem like the business is getting more work done, in the long run, it's counterproductive as tired employees might not work efficiently or might even make mistakes.

3. Organizational reputation

A company's reputation is its most valuable asset. If word gets out that a company frequently allows unauthorized overtime or doesn't pay unauthorized overtime fairly, it can harm its image. Clients or customers might perceive the company as one that doesn't value its employees.

Moreover, for future hires, work-life balance is a top priority. If they feel that a company leans heavily towards overtime, attracting top talent can become challenging.

Strategies to prevent unauthorized overtime

Employer using a shift management tool to create employee shift schedules

Unauthorized overtime can strain both company resources and employee well-being. Here are effective strategies that employers can adopt to curb the occurrence of unauthorized overtime:

Clear communication

One of the primary reasons for unauthorized overtime is the lack of clarity.

  • Establishing and communicating clear policies regarding overtime: It's not enough just to have a policy; it should be well-communicated. Every employee, from a newbie to a seasoned worker, should understand when and how they can work overtime. This clarity reduces the chances of unintentional breaches.

  • Regular check-ins and updates between employees and supervisors: Open channels of communication between team members and their leaders can help spot potential overtime issues before they escalate. These check-ins also provide opportunities to clarify doubts and give feedback.

Technology and tools

Modern problems require modern solutions.

  • Implementing time-tracking software: Such tools can automatically flag when an employee is nearing their maximum allowed hours, alerting both the employee and the supervisor. This real-time tracking ensures that unauthorized overtime is caught and addressed promptly.

  • Using project management tools to streamline tasks: When tasks are organized, and everyone knows their responsibilities, it reduces the likelihood of last-minute rushes that lead to overtime.

Employee training

Equip your employees with the right skills and knowledge.

  • Regular workshops on time management: Time is money. Teaching employees how to manage their time can prevent unnecessary overtime. Such workshops can offer techniques on prioritizing tasks, setting realistic goals, and efficiently managing workloads.

  • Training on company policies related to work hours and compensation: Periodic training sessions can serve as refreshers about company policies, ensuring that all team members are on the same page.

Useful Read: Time Off in Lieu (TOIL): Balancing Employee Rewards and Work-Life Harmony

Leadership and culture

The company's culture is often a reflection of its leadership.

  • Promoting a culture of work-life balance: When employees see that the company values their personal time, they're less likely to push themselves into unauthorized overtime. Encouraging breaks, taking time off, and emphasizing the importance of rest can set a positive tone.

  • Ensuring leaders set the right example by avoiding excessive work hours: Leaders are role models. If they're burning the midnight oil, employees might feel compelled to do the same. Leaders should embody the values and practices they want their teams to adopt.

In essence, preventing unauthorized overtime is a blend of clear policies, leveraging technology, continuous training, and fostering a supportive work culture. With these strategies in place, companies can create a balanced environment that respects both organizational goals and employee welfare.

Employee scheduling and Time-tracking software!

Employee scheduling and Time-tracking software!

  • Easy Employee scheduling
  • Clear time-tracking
  • Simple absence management
Try for free Request a demo


Navigating overtime is crucial for employers and employees alike. Differentiating between authorized and unauthorized overtime ensures fair compensation and promotes a balanced work environment.

Staying informed and fostering clear communication can help businesses strike the right balance, ensuring both operational efficiency and employee well-being.

Manage unauthorized overtime effectively with Shiftbase

Unauthorized overtime can be a hassle, but it's manageable with the right approach and tools. Shiftbase offers robust features like employee scheduling and time tracking that help you maintain control over work hours, thus preventing unauthorized overtime. Our software also ensures you're compliant with labor laws, helping you avoid unwanted penalties.

Worried about unauthorized overtime affecting your business? Start a free 14-day trial with Shiftbase to regain control and ensure legal compliance.

Topic: Overtime
Rinaily Bonifacio

Written by:

Rinaily Bonifacio

Rinaily is a renowned expert in the field of human resources with years of industry experience. With a passion for writing high-quality HR content, Rinaily brings a unique perspective to the challenges and opportunities of the modern workplace. As an experienced HR professional and content writer, She has contributed to leading publications in the field of HR.


Please note that the information on our website is intended for general informational purposes and not as binding advice. The information on our website cannot be considered a substitute for legal and binding advice for any specific situation. While we strive to provide up-to-date and accurate information, we do not guarantee the accuracy, completeness and timeliness of the information on our website for any purpose. We are not liable for any damage or loss arising from the use of the information on our website.