Would you like to view this website in another language?

Is Your Excel Rota Toxic? Time to Switch to Scheduling Software

women throwing away her work schedule excel sheet in the bin

The answer is a resounding yes — because you deserve a scheduling system that gives you peace of mind, not sleepless nights.

Valentine’s Day is just around the corner and the bookings are rolling in. But while your customers are focused on each other, you’re probably staring at a rota that somehow doesn’t add up — again. In hospitality and retail, 14 February can make or break the day, but for plenty of managers it feels more like a relationship stress test… with their current scheduling setup.

Still working with outdated spreadsheets or a system that refuses to cooperate? Then chances are you’re showing all the classic signs of a bad relationship. It hurts to admit it, but sometimes the love is gone — and it’s time to look for a “partner” that actually listens to you.

📊 Is your relationship with Excel still healthy?

Tick what sounds familiar — and be honest with yourself 😉

Sound familiar?
Maybe it’s time for relationship therapy. Or you could make life easier and go on a date with a system that actually thinks along with you — one that listens, gives you clarity, and doesn’t get difficult when last-minute changes pop up 😉

3 signs your relationship with Excel is “toxic”

It used to be simple — you completely understood each other. You had a small team, a tidy little file, and that was enough. But your business has grown and times have changed, while your spreadsheet is still stuck in the past. On peak days like Valentine’s Day, the cracks in the relationship show up fast. Finding yourself getting more and more frustrated with the rota? Chances are you’ll recognise these three red flags.

1. Communication is poor

You add the rota to the file and email it around… and then your phone blows up. You get three WhatsApps, a sticky note on your desk, and an email back saying someone can’t work after all. The result: pure chaos and crossed wires. On the busiest night of the year, you suddenly end up one person short behind the bar — because Excel didn’t “mention” that Bart has an evening class. In a healthy relationship (and a well-run business), clear communication is the foundation. A static spreadsheet, however, can’t talk back.

2. It drains you

A good partner gives you energy. A bad one takes it. Ask yourself how many hours you spend every week fixing broken formulas, manually copying hours over, and shuffling shifts until it somehow fits. If you’re lying awake at night worrying about the rota instead of dreaming about great sales figures, it’s time to pull the plug. Your workforce scheduling software should work for you — not against you.

3. You don’t get support when it really matters

On a day like Valentine’s Day, you want to know exactly where you stand. Are we breaking even? Are labour costs still in line with expected revenue? Your spreadsheet probably just stares back at you with empty cells. It doesn’t offer insights, forecasts, or warnings when you’re about to blow your budget. When it’s crunch time, you’re on your own — exactly when you could really use a bit of backup.

Example: last-minute rota stress 😅
How it usually goes in the group chat…
Valentine’s • 13:42
Manager
Team, the Valentine’s rota has been emailed!
13:42
Lisa
Wait — didn’t I request this day off? 😅
13:43
Mo
I’m scheduled in, but I’m at college until 5pm…
13:43
Manager
Okay, I’ll adjust it again… one sec.
13:44
● ● ● Manager is typing…
💡Tip: With Shiftbase, this doesn’t have to happen via messages: request → approve → update automatically.

Time for a new love: Shiftbase

Breaking up is hard — especially when you’ve been together for years. Maybe you’re thinking, “But I know exactly how this file works.” That’s usually just fear of the unknown, because the truth is: you deserve better. There are plenty of better fish in the sea — and they can make your life a whole lot easier. Shiftbase is the “partner” that actually ticks all the boxes and understands what you need.

Imagine a partner who doesn’t just take, but also gives. While Excel has you spending hours trying to make everything fit, smart workforce scheduling software takes the heavy lifting off your plate. Here’s what you can expect from a healthy relationship with your system:

  • It actually listens to you: Where your old setup was conveniently deaf, Shiftbase is all ears. Employees use the app to share their availability and time-off requests. You approve or decline — and it’s instantly confirmed in the rota. No more mixed signals, just clear agreements everyone can rely on.

  • It’s flexible and thinks along with you: Plans change — especially in hospitality. Need to swap a shift? It’s sorted in two clicks, and the relevant employees get a notification straight away. The system works with you, not against you, so you’ve got headspace for the things that actually matter.

  • It backs you up when it’s busy: This might be the best part. Shiftbase shows you in real time whether you’re staying within budget. While the receipt printer is going non-stop on Valentine’s Day, you can glance at your screen and see your labour costs are still under control. That’s the kind of support you need to stay calm and confident on the floor.

❌ The Ex (Excel)

  • Hobbies: Freezing, crashing, and “forgetting” formulas.
  • Communication: Email only (if you’re lucky).
  • Personality: Static, cold, and distant.
  • Cost: Loads of time and frustration.

✅ The New Match (Shiftbase)

  • Hobbies: Saving time and giving you real insight.
  • Communication: Available 24/7 via the app.
  • Personality: Flexible, smart, and supportive.
  • Cost: A fixed low fee (and it pays for itself!).

Love at first sight

Do you remember what it feels like to fall in love? That light, buzzy feeling in your head — the energy it gives you. That’s exactly what good software can do for you. The moment you make the switch, you’ll notice the difference straight away. No more mess with random notes lying around or endless phone calls — just a calmer, smoother operation.

And it’s not only about saving you time — your team will be happier too. Staff know exactly where they stand, can request time off easily, and always have their rota in their pocket. A happier team creates a better atmosphere on the floor, and that shows in the experience your customers get. And really, that’s the whole point: delivering great service without the admin chaos distracting you.

Choose yourself (and your team)

Valentine’s Day is the perfect moment to stop settling for less. You don’t have to keep muddling through with a system that frustrates you. Break up with those static spreadsheets and choose a solution that gets your hospitality heart beating for the right reasons. Happy staff, happy you, happy customers.

Ready to break the cycle?

💙 Valentine’s card
For: you ✨
💌 A little note from Shiftbase

Go on a date with Shiftbase

No need to get married straight away — you can get to know us first. Start your free 14-day trial today. We promise to handle your data properly and to genuinely have your back when things get busy. Trust us: you won’t miss your old Ex(cel) one bit.

With love (and perfectly planned rotas),

Team Shiftbase 💙

Try Shiftbase free for 14 days →

P.S. We’ll keep treating your data properly — and we’re genuinely there when it gets busy.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Even though Excel is free to use, it often costs you a lot in “hidden” hours. You lose time every week manually piecing the rota together, messaging staff back and forth, and fixing mistakes. Workforce scheduling software saves you that time, helps prevent expensive misunderstandings, and gives you instant visibility into labour costs — which quickly pays for itself.

  • No. Modern tools like Shiftbase are built for usability. You can usually create an account and invite your team in just a few minutes. And because the interface is intuitive, you don’t need to wade through long manuals. In many cases, switching now is easier than continuing to struggle with a system that isn’t working.

  • Yes — that’s one of the biggest advantages of cloud-based software. An Excel sheet is often unreadable on a mobile screen, but tools like Shiftbase have a dedicated app. As a manager, you can update rotas from anywhere, and employees can use their own phones to view shifts, swap them, or request time off.

  • Absolutely. A smart system gives you insight into expected labour costs compared to your revenue while you’re building the rota — so you can spot immediately if you’re scheduling too expensively. On top of that, it tracks actual worked hours accurately, so you don’t accidentally overpay due to rounding or spreadsheet errors.

Employee scheduling and Time-tracking software!
Employee scheduling and Time-tracking software!
  • Easy Employee scheduling
  • Clear time-tracking
  • Simple absence management
Try for free Request a demo

 

employee scheduling

Written by:

Rinaily Bonifacio

Rinaily is a renowned expert in the field of human resources with years of industry experience. With a passion for writing high-quality HR content, Rinaily brings a unique perspective to the challenges and opportunities of the modern workplace. As an experienced HR professional and content writer, She has contributed to leading publications in the field of HR.

Disclaimer

Please note that the information on our website is intended for general informational purposes and not as binding advice. The information on our website cannot be considered a substitute for legal and binding advice for any specific situation. While we strive to provide up-to-date and accurate information, we do not guarantee the accuracy, completeness and timeliness of the information on our website for any purpose. We are not liable for any damage or loss arising from the use of the information on our website.

Start saving time on your employee scheduling

14 days trial, free support

  • Easy to manage
  • Simple to share with employees
  • Always up-to-date
Use Shiftbase on mobile