Shiftbase vs Papershift: Which Rota Tool is The Best Fit For Your Business?

Juggling rotas in Excel, last-minute swaps on WhatsApp, and payroll checks at midnight? If you’re comparing Shiftbase and Papershift, you’re likely trying to stop the chaos without overspending or risking compliance fines.

This guide gives you a clear, side-by-side view of both platforms through an EU lens: real pricing, everyday usability, labour-law controls, integrations with payroll/POS, and the kind of support you actually get. By the end, you’ll know exactly which tool matches your size, budget, and operations, and how to test it with minimal risk.

Shiftbase VS Papershift at a glance

Here is a side-by-side view to compare, evaluate, and choose the right HR software scheduling tool for your business.

Dimension	Shiftbase	Papershift
Pricing model	Tiered plans; Premium includes first 12 employees, then €5 per extra employee. 14-day free trial.	Fixed base fee €39/month on any plan (plus user/modules).
Typical fit	SMEs wanting flexible per-employee scaling and cost control.	Teams OK with a fixed platform charge and add-ons.
Core features	Scheduling, time tracking, absence, mobile app, payroll/POS integrations.	Scheduling, time tracking, absence, payroll add-ons, mobile apps.
Compliance focus	Timesheets/approvals, auditability; help centre documentation and updates.	Accurate hour calculation and rota→payroll workflow.
Support	Help centre + live support; onboarding guidance noted on pricing page.	Human assistance + Ai chatbot available

➗ Mini-verdict: For small EU teams, avoiding a mandatory base fee often lowers 12-month TCO. Shiftbase is usually the leaner start; Papershift suits buyers comfortable with a platform base fee and add-ons. (Model your actual headcount.)

Key decision factors based on SME priorities

Focus on five make-or-break factors (pricing, usability, compliance, integrations, and support) because they ultimately decide ROI and rollout speed for EU SMEs.

Pricing & scalability

If you’re running lean, the pricing model matters more than the sticker price. Shiftbase Premium includes the first 12 employees and adds €5 per extra, which scales predictably with headcount; there’s also a 14-day free trial to evaluate. Papershift applies a €39/month base fee to any plan, which can be efficient at larger scale but adds fixed overhead for micro-teams. Compare, evaluate, and choose based on a 12-month total cost, not monthly headlines.

💡Under ~15 staff, per-employee pricing tends to be kinder to cash flow.

Usability & rollout speed

Both products promote quick setup: drag-and-drop scheduling, mobile access, and rota-to-payroll workflows. Papershift leans into “whole online HR solution” messaging with friendly support; Shiftbase highlights straightforward WFM with clear feature categories and EU-friendly terminology. In practice, aim to publish your first rota within week one and test staff self-service (availability, swaps) before go-live.

Compliance & labour-law safeguards

EU compliance lives in the details: break rules, maximum hours, overtime surcharges, approvals, and audit logs. Shiftbase’s help centre shows extensive content around timesheets, approvals, and ongoing 2025 updates—use these controls to prevent issues before payroll. Papershift focuses on clean rota→payroll flow; ensure your policy rules are reflected in templates and overtime calculations. Document your audit trail regardless of vendor.

💡 If your exposure is fines/back pay, prioritise pre-publish checks and approval workflows.

Integrations (payroll, POS, HR)

You’ll save the most time when scheduling and time tracking feed existing payroll/POS. Shiftbase documents integrations via its help centre (payroll/POS/HR categories) and public site; map your stack and test exports in the trial. Papershift provides integrations and automation routes as well—verify specific connectors you need (payroll first). The real win is error-free hours → payroll without CSV wrangling.

💡 Prioritise native/payroll connectors you’ll actually use weekly.

Support & onboarding

Shiftbase offers an active Help Center plus full support desk and onboarding assistance (listed on the pricing and onboarding pages). Papershift provides human support and adds Papershift Pulse, an AI assistant for routine HR queries and workflows.

Verdict line: Pick the team that fixes a real configuration during trial—AI can speed first answers, but human resolution before payroll is what counts.Pros & cons (at a glance)

	Shiftbase	Papershift
Pros	• SME-friendly pricing: Premium includes first 12 employees, then per-employee add-on (predictable TCO). • Documented EU results: customers report up to 80% time saved after moving off spreadsheets. • Strong enablement: active help centre and guided onboarding noted on pricing.	• Clear “rota→timesheet→payroll” storyline in one tool; fast onboarding/demo flow. • Broad coverage (rota, time, absence, payroll workflows) in one platform.
Cons	• Some advanced features may sit in higher tiers—confirm must-haves in trial.	• €39/month base fee applies to any plan (adds fixed cost for small teams). • Package/add-on complexity—check what’s included (e.g., automatic rostering).
Best for…	Cost-conscious SMEs wanting predictable per-employee scaling, strong compliance posture, and published ROI evidence.	Buyers who prefer an all-in-one narrative and are comfortable with a base platform fee and add-ons.

Real-world use cases

Real teams, real metrics: see how organisations (from museums to multi-site hospitality) cut rota admin, smooth payroll, and prove time-savings after ditching spreadsheets.

Moco Museum Barcelona moved from Excel to Shiftbase and reports up to 80% time saved on scheduling/admin after rollout. That freed managers to focus on visitor flow and staffing quality instead of paperwork. If your team still shares rotas via spreadsheets or WhatsApp, this is the kind of win to expect once timesheets and leave sit in one place.

💡Takeaway: High manual overhead? Shiftbase shows strong returns when replacing spreadsheets in culture/recreation orgs.
The National Museum of World Cultures implemented Shiftbase across multiple locations and achieved 20% time saved on scheduling for 14 coordinators, plus 2 hours/month saved on approvals for five team leaders. For SMEs with several sites or departments, centralising rotas and approvals can deliver quick, tangible gains.

💡Takeaway: Multi-location teams benefit from shared visibility and streamlined approvals.
Papershift pitches an all-in-one flow (rota, timesheet, to payroll) and backs it with customer results. YoungCapital reports ~10 hours saved per week on planning after adopting Papershift, highlighting faster rota creation and cleaner hand-off to payroll. Use the trial to replicate this: time a real export and a payroll run, and compare admin minutes saved against your baseline.

💡Takeaway: Prefer a single-vendor rota→payroll story? Papershift’s proposition is clear — just test it end-to-end with your own data before you decide.

➗ Final verdict:

If you’re optimising costs for a small EU team, Shiftbase’s pricing avoids a fixed platform fee and scales predictably with headcount (Premium includes your first 12 employees, then a clear per-employee add-on). Papershift adds a €39/month base fee to any plan—fine if you want an all-in-one narrative and you’re comfortable with a fixed overhead. Model a 12-month TCO using your actual headcount and locations.

Why this matters:

Cost control: Per-employee vs base-fee economics can swing ROI for micro-SMEs.
Proof of impact: Shiftbase publishes measurable wins (e.g., ~80% time saved at Moco Museum; 20% scheduling time saved at the National Museum of World Cultures).
Operating reality: If you want a tight rota→timesheet→payroll storyline with a guided demo, Papershift leans hard into that promise.

👉 What you should do next:

Run a one-week pilot with both tools. Publish two rota templates, connect payroll/POS, and track: manager hours saved, overtime variance, and export-to-payroll time. Keep whichever scores higher on cost, compliance, and speed. Start the Shiftbase trial (14 days) and request a Papershift demo to replicate the same test conditions.

Employee scheduling and Time-tracking software!

Easy Employee scheduling
Clear time-tracking
Simple absence management

Try for free Request a demo

Frequently Asked Questions

For micro-teams, avoiding a base fee often lowers TCO. Shiftbase Premium includes your first 12 employees; Papershift applies a €39/month base fee on any plan (plus users/modules). Always compare 12-month totals.
Both cover rota, time, absence and payroll workflows. Papershift pushes an end-to-end rota→payroll message, while Shiftbase documents deep timesheets/approvals you can configure pre-payroll—test both during your pilot.
Yes. Moco Museum Barcelona reports ~80% time saved after moving from Excel to Shiftbase. The National Museum of World Cultures reports 20% scheduling time saved across three locations.
Both vendors promote fast onboarding. Shiftbase offers a 14-day free trial; Papershift offers a guided demo/product tour—time an export-to-payroll run in week one to validate speed.
Evaluate support quality during trial: submit a real configuration question (break rules or overtime surcharges) to each vendor. Both advertise accessible support; choose the team that resolves a concrete scenario fast.