Still Creating Your Work schedule in Excel? Here's 5 Reason Why its Time For a Change!

mature woman using laptop to plan work schedules

Have you ever found yourself lost in the labyrinth of an Excel spreadsheet, trying to untangle the complex web of work schedules? You're not alone. Many employers, HR managers, and small business owners resort to the familiar comfort of Microsoft Excel, armed with an array of daily schedule templates and color codes, in a valiant effort to organize the chaos of daily work schedules, weekly plans, and employee shift schedules.

But let's face it, while Excel's gridlines may look neat and tidy, they often hide a deeper turmoil beneath. A turmoil of time-consuming manual entries, a constant battle against errors, and a juggling act of updating, sharing, and integrating these schedules with other essential business processes. It’s like trying to fit a square peg in a round hole.

So, why continue down this path? In this blog, we'll delve into the reasons why it's time to rethink your reliance on Excel for scheduling and embrace a change that could revolutionize how you manage projects, your workforce and, ultimately, contribute to your business success.

The limitations of excel scheduling

Lets dive into 5 limitations of an excel schedule template that every manager should consider:

1. The time trap: manual scheduling in excel

Imagine managing the daily work schedule of a dynamic team. Each member has their unique availability, preferences, and work hours.

As the planner, you’re not just creating a weekly schedule; you’re also a detective, piecing together the intricate puzzle of availability, shifts, and business needs.

This is where the time trap of Excel reveals itself. Every change, swap, or update means sifting through rows and columns, ensuring no double-bookings or overlooked requests. It’s a meticulous, often painstaking process, and let’s be honest, it’s hardly the most effective use of your time.

Excel, for all its merits in handling data and creating basic employee shift schedule templates, falls short when it comes to dynamic and efficient scheduling.

The manual process, often riddled with repetitive tasks and constant checks for errors, can be a drain on your most valuable resource: time. It’s a time trap, one that savvy employers and HR managers are increasingly keen to escape.

2. Error prone: the downside of manual entries and formulas

The manual entry of data, a staple in creating Excel schedules, is akin to walking a tightrope without a safety net.

One slip – a mistyped hour, a misplaced decimal, an incorrect formula – and the entire schedule could topple into chaos.

These errors, seemingly small, can have substantial repercussions, from miscalculating work hours to mismanaging employee shifts.

Moreover, the reliance on formulas in Excel can be a double-edged sword. While they're powerful tools for organizing and calculating data, they're also susceptible to missteps. A single erroneous formula can cascade through your schedule, leading to inaccuracies that can go unnoticed until they cause significant disruptions.

This susceptibility transforms your scheduling process into a minefield, where constant vigilance is required to avoid missteps, making the process not just error-prone but also stress-inducing.

3. The missing piece: lack of automation in excel scheduling

The lack of automation when creating a shift schedule in excel, turns what should be a streamlined process into a manual marathon. Real-time updates and automatic adjustments are not just conveniences; they're necessities.

Excel, with its static templates and manual entry requirements, falls behind in this race. It lacks the ability to adapt quickly to changes or auto-populate data based on preset criteria.

This means every shift change, employee absence, or new project requires a hands-on approach. You're constantly updating, revising, and double-checking.

It's not just inefficient; it's a missed opportunity to leverage technology for smarter, more effective scheduling.

The result? A time-consuming process that could otherwise be a quick, automated task, freeing you up for more strategic endeavors like managing projects, enhancing communication features, or focusing on business success.

4. Collaboration challenges: sharing and updating excel schedules

When it comes to collaboration, Excel schedules can feel like trying to play a team sport where everyone's using different rulebooks.

Sharing these schedules often means sending attachments back and forth, leading to multiple versions floating around. It's like a game of telephone but with Excel files – what starts as a clear schedule often ends up as a mishmash of confusion.

Updating these schedules isn't any simpler. Ever tried to make real-time changes to a shared Excel file? It's like a juggling act where everyone's juggling their own set of balls. Lack of real-time updates means you could be making changes on an outdated version, only to realize someone else has already made different adjustments.

This lack of synchronization isn't just frustrating; it's a recipe for miscommunication, potentially leading to scheduling mishaps and unhappy teams.

In a nutshell, Excel might be great for solo projects, but when it comes to team scheduling, it's like trying to fit a square peg in a round hole.

5. Isolation issues: excel and the lack of system integration

Excel might feel like a familiar old friend for scheduling, but it's often the friend who doesn't play well with others. One of its biggest shortcomings? A striking lack of integration with other business systems. In an era where everything is interconnected, Excel stands on an island, isolated.

This means your painstakingly crafted schedules in Excel don't seamlessly sync with other critical systems like timekeeping, payroll, or project management tools.

The result? A fragmented workflow where you're manually transferring data between systems. You miss out on the power of integration, which in the business world, is akin to working with one hand tied behind your back.

This isolation not only complicates processes but also opens doors to errors and inefficiencies, undermining the very purpose of using a tool meant to simplify your work life.

Embracing dedicated scheduling software

Female employee using shiftbase planning tool - employee scheduling

It's time to break up with Excel and start a new relationship with dedicated scheduling software. Enter Shiftbase, a SaaS solution that's like a breath of fresh air in the world of workforce management. Picture this: a world where schedules self-adjust, time tracking is a breeze, and absence management is no longer a game of detective. That's the world Shiftbase offers.

Shiftbase takes the puzzle out of employee scheduling, introducing automation that Excel can only dream of. Gone are the days of manual entries and constant updates.

Instead, imagine a system where shifts align themselves based on employee availability, preferences, and business needs - all in real-time. It's like having a scheduling wizard at your fingertips.

Time tracking is another area where Shiftbase shines. With features like time and attendance tracking, a time clock, and a punch clock, it turns what was once a tedious task into a smooth, automated process.

No more sifting through timesheets or questioning hours worked. Everything is tracked accurately and efficiently, right down to the minute.

But wait, there's more. The Shiftbase mobile app revolutionizes how employees interact with their schedules.

They can manage hours, request leave, or ask for time off, all from the palm of their hands. It's like giving each employee a personal scheduling assistant, enhancing communication and empowerment within the team.

In essence, Shiftbase isn't just a tool; it's a game changer. It offers the efficiency, accuracy, and ease of use that Excel lacks, tailored specifically for the dynamic world of workforce management.

By embracing Shiftbase, you're not just upgrading your scheduling system; you're elevating your entire approach to managing your most valuable asset - your people.

Real world case studies

Let's look at 2 examples of companies that made the switch from excel work schedule templates to automated scheduling, and never looked back:

Social Capital and Happy Tosti's transformation with Shiftbase

Social Capital, a company known for creating inclusive workplaces under its umbrella including Happy Tosti, faced a complex challenge in time tracking and employee scheduling due to rapid expansion.

Their previous methods ranged from Excel spreadsheets to unstructured approaches, causing confusion and inefficiencies. The introduction of Shiftbase since 2016 marked a turning point. This user-friendly system brought uniformity, clarity, and insightful KPIs, greatly simplifying schedules and time tracking.

The results were transformative: improved wage cost insights, enhanced clarity for employees and supervisors, real-time turnover insights, and easy integration with other systems. Shiftbase didn't just streamline Social Capital's operations; it adapted and grew with their needs, demonstrating its value as a crucial tool for effective workforce management. Read the full story here!

Escape Amsterdam’s shift from Excel to Shiftbase

Escape Amsterdam, a bustling nightclub, faced significant challenges with Excel for scheduling its 150 employees.

The manual process was time-consuming and error-prone, often leading to scheduling errors and inefficient time tracking. In 2022, they switched to Shiftbase, transforming their staff management.

This move not only saved 30% in time on managing availability but also reduced scheduling efforts significantly. With Shiftbase, Escape Amsterdam enhanced employee engagement, as staff could easily access and manage their schedules. This switch from Excel to a dedicated tool like Shiftbase underscores its effectiveness in streamlining workforce management in dynamic environments. Read the full story here!

In the mood for more case studies? Click here for more!

Employee scheduling and Time-tracking software!
Employee scheduling and Time-tracking software!
  • Easy Employee scheduling
  • Clear time-tracking
  • Simple absence management
Try for free Request a demo


In the grand scheme of managing a workforce, the transition from traditional methods like Excel to innovative solutions like Shiftbase is not just a change; it's an evolution. Excel, with its manual entries and static templates, might feel safe and familiar, but as we've seen, it's akin to navigating a boat with an outdated map. The real treasure lies in embracing tools designed specifically for the challenges and dynamics of modern workforce management.

So, as we wrap up, let's remember that the right tools can make all the difference. Whether you're a small business owner, an HR manager, or a team leader, the shift to a system like Shiftbase could be the pivotal step towards more effective, efficient, and enjoyable workforce management. It's not just about scheduling; it's about elevating your business to its full potential.