Pay mix

Pay mix is the split between fixed pay and variable pay in what an employee earns at target, usually written as a ratio such as 70/30.

Written by: Rinaily BonifacioUpdated on:

What is pay mix?

Pay mix is the split between fixed pay and variable pay in what an employee earns when they hit their targets, written as a ratio such as 70/30. The first number is the guaranteed part: base salary or an hourly rate. The second is the part that depends on results: commission, target bonuses, and other incentive pay.

The ratio is set on target earnings, not on what someone was actually paid last year. A sales rep on a 70/30 mix with £50,000 on-target earnings (OTE) has £35,000 guaranteed and £15,000 that depends on hitting quota. In a strong year the rep may earn £62,000 and in a weak one £41,000, but the pay mix stays 70/30, because it describes the plan, not the outcome.

So the two types of compensation in a pay mix are fixed and variable. Benefits such as pension and health cover are usually left out of the ratio and shown separately as part of total compensation, since they don't move with performance. Pay mix also differs from pay level: pay level is how much the role earns in total compared with the market, pay mix is how that total is split. Both are choices in a wider compensation strategy.

How to calculate the pay mix ratio

You need two figures per role: the fixed pay for a year and the variable pay at 100% of target. Then:

  • On-target earnings = fixed pay + target variable pay

  • Fixed share = fixed pay ÷ on-target earnings

  • Variable share = target variable pay ÷ on-target earnings

Take an account executive with a base salary of £36,000 and a commission target of £24,000. On-target earnings are £60,000. The fixed share is 36,000 ÷ 60,000 = 60%, the variable share 24,000 ÷ 60,000 = 40%, so the pay mix is 60/40. A colleague on £48,000 base and £12,000 target bonus also has £60,000 OTE, but an 80/20 mix: the same pay level with a very different amount at risk.

For hourly staff the calculation works the same way, only per week or per period. Use contracted hours times the hourly rate as the fixed part, and the expected commission or bonus over the same period as the variable part.

What happens above and below target

The ratio says nothing about how fast variable pay grows past target, and that is where most of the cost and the motivation sit. Compensation consultants call it leverage or upside: what a top performer earns compared with OTE. A 60/40 plan with an accelerator might pay double the target commission at 150% of quota.

Attainment

Base

Commission paid

Total pay

Variable share of actual pay

50% of quota

£36,000

£12,000

£48,000

25%

100% of quota

£36,000

£24,000

£60,000

40%

150% of quota, 2x rate above target

£36,000

£48,000

£84,000

57%

This is the 60/40 account executive from above, with commission paid at the plain rate up to quota and at twice that rate above it. The pay mix is still 60/40 in all three rows; only the actual split moves. When people compare their plans, make sure everyone is talking about the target split and not last year's payslips.

Typical splits by role

The more control a role has over the result, and the shorter the path from effort to a closed deal, the more of its pay tends to be variable. WorldatWork gives account managers a pay mix around 65/35, new-business hunters 50/50, and strategic account managers 75/25. Roles further from the sale lean further towards fixed pay:

Role

Usual direction of the mix

Why

New-business sales (hunters)

Around 50/50

Results are measurable per person and the deal is theirs

Account managers

Around 65/35

Revenue partly comes from existing customers

Strategic or enterprise account managers

Around 75/25

Long cycles, many people involved in each deal

Sales development (lead qualification)

Mostly fixed

Activity is measurable, revenue is credited to others

Office, operations, and service roles

Fixed, sometimes a small bonus

Output is hard to tie to one person

Hourly frontline staff

Fixed, with premiums, tips, or a small commission

Earnings depend mainly on the hours scheduled

Treat these as starting points. A pay mix that suits one company's sales cycle can be wrong for a competitor selling the same product with a longer cycle or more people per deal.

Pay mix for hourly and frontline staff

Most writing on pay mix is about sales teams on annual salaries. In retail and hospitality the same question comes up per hour, and the answer is usually a much smaller variable share, because a sales assistant controls neither the footfall nor the rota.

Take a shop assistant contracted for 30 hours a week at £14.00 an hour, with 2% commission on their own sales above a weekly target. In a normal week the target is passed by £2,000, so commission is £40. Fixed pay is £420, on-target pay £460, and the pay mix is roughly 91/9. A shift on a Sunday or a late evening may add a shift premium, but that follows from the schedule, not from performance, so it doesn't belong in the variable share of a pay mix even though it varies week to week.

Tips are different again. In hospitality they can be a large part of what a waiter takes home, but they come from guests, not from the employer's pay plan. In the UK all tips must be passed to workers without deductions, often through a tronc, a separate system for sharing them out. They sit outside the pay mix you design.

What counts towards the UK minimum wage

Variable pay changes what an employer can count when checking minimum wage pay, so the fixed part of an hourly pay mix needs to hold up on its own:

  • Bonuses, sales commission, and other performance-related pay count towards minimum wage pay.

  • Most of an annual bonus counts only in the pay reference period it is paid in, and a pay reference period is never longer than a calendar month. A year-end bonus does not make up for low pay earlier in the year.

  • Tips, gratuities, service charges, and cover charges do not count.

  • The premium element of overtime and shift premiums does not count; only the basic rate for those hours does.

These rules come from the government guidance on calculating the minimum wage on gov.uk. A worker on a heavily variable plan still has to be paid at least the minimum wage, on average, for the hours worked in each pay reference period.

Choosing the split for a role

Start from what the role can actually influence. If an employee closes their own deals and the result shows up within weeks, a larger variable share rewards the people who sell and costs less in a slow quarter. If the result depends on marketing, a team, the season, or the schedule, a large variable share mostly moves risk onto the employee without changing what they do.

Three more questions narrow it down. How long is the cycle from first contact to revenue? The longer it is, the more fixed pay the role needs to get through dry months. How cleanly can results be credited to one person? Shared deals need credit rules before they need a bigger variable share. And how predictable does labour cost need to be? A business with tight margins and seasonal peaks often prefers fixed pay plus a discretionary bonus at year end over commission that swings with every month.

Whatever split you pick, write down how the variable part is calculated, with one worked example per role, so that employees can recalculate their own pay and managers apply the plan in the same way.

Mistakes that make variable pay backfire

Changing the mix without changing OTE. Moving a role from 80/20 to 60/40 at the same on-target earnings is a cut in guaranteed pay. Employees read it that way, whatever the plan document calls it.

Paying variable pay on things the role does not control. Commission for a shop assistant on total store revenue rewards whoever was scheduled on the busy Saturday. Tie it to their own sales or to something the team can change.

Comparing plans on actual pay. Last year's payout reflects last year's market. Benchmark the target split and OTE, then look at payouts separately.

A base that only works with commission. When fixed pay alone sits below the minimum wage and commission is meant to top it up, a weak month can leave average pay for that pay reference period under the minimum.

Where Shiftbase fits

Shiftbase does not design pay plans, calculate commission, or run payroll. For hourly teams it records the fixed side of the mix as it happens: scheduled and worked hours, clock-ins, breaks, overtime, and surcharges such as shift premiums, checked and closed per department before the period ends. Teams then prepare payroll by exporting those hours to their payroll provider, such as Nmbrs, AFAS, Loket, Exact Online, or SD Worx, or as an Excel or CSV file, and add commission and bonuses there.

Frequently asked questions

Pay mix is the split between fixed pay and variable pay in an employee's on-target earnings, written as a ratio such as 70/30. The first number is the guaranteed base pay, the second the commission or bonus paid at 100% of target.

A 70/30 pay mix means 70% of on-target earnings is fixed base pay and 30% is variable pay earned by hitting targets. With £50,000 on-target earnings, that is £35,000 base and £15,000 in commission or bonus at 100% of quota.

You calculate a pay mix ratio by dividing fixed pay by on-target earnings for the fixed share, and target variable pay by on-target earnings for the variable share. £36,000 base and £24,000 target commission give £60,000 OTE and a 60/40 pay mix.

Fixed pay is the guaranteed part of pay, such as a base salary or an hourly rate, paid whatever the results. Variable pay depends on performance, such as sales commission, target bonuses, or profit sharing, and changes from period to period.

Pay mix is not the same as pay ratio. Pay mix is the split between fixed and variable pay within one role. Pay ratio usually compares what different people earn, such as the CEO pay ratio between the chief executive and the median employee.

Commission and bonuses count towards minimum wage pay in the UK, but tips, gratuities, service charges, and cover charges do not. The premium part of overtime and shift premiums does not count either, so the basic hourly rate has to reach the minimum wage on its own.

Hourly retail and hospitality staff usually have a pay mix that is almost entirely fixed, because their earnings depend mostly on the hours they are scheduled. A small commission on their own sales, or a bonus at the end of a season, keeps the variable share small.

Rinaily Bonifacio
Rinaily BonifacioSenior Content Marketer

Rinaily writes for Shiftbase about HR, scheduling and building teams people actually want to work in. She turns the messy reality of workforce planning into practical advice you can put to work today.

See all terms