Padding Hours Explained: How Employers Can Detect and Stop Time Theft

This article explains what “padding hours” means, how it impacts payroll and productivity, and how employers can detect, prevent, and address time theft effectively. You’ll also learn the legal and ethical angles so you handle it properly.

What is padding hours?

Padding hours is when employees exaggerate or inflate time worked. It often shows up as rounded start/end times, unrecorded or extended breaks, buddy punching, or forgetting to deduct breaks.

Common methods of padding hours

Here are the practices HR managers most often see.

Manual rounding & paper-based entries

Manual timesheets invite errors or manipulation. For example, an employee who starts at 09:07 logs 09:00, and who leaves at 16:53 logs 17:00. Small gaps compound over time.

Note (US): Under the FLSA, limited rounding (e.g., to the nearest 5, 10, or 15 minutes) can be lawful if it’s neutral and, over time, doesn’t consistently overpay or underpay. Make sure your policy and system are genuinely neutral and consistent.

Buddy punching (clocking for someone else)

Buddy punching is a direct form of falsification—e.g., one employee clocks in for a colleague who’s late. It inflates payroll costs, rewards dishonesty, and harms team morale.

Extended or untracked breaks & personal time

Padded hours also occur when breaks aren’t deducted correctly, or when personal tasks creep into paid time without logging adjustments.

Impact on business operations & payroll

Financial cost

Even small daily exaggerations can meaningfully inflate labour spend and knock-on overtime. As an illustration, if a company spends £500,000 on payroll, a one–two percent creep from padded time would mean £5,000–£10,000 in avoidable cost.

Productivity & scheduling

• Overestimated capacity → missed deadlines.
• Unnecessary overtime or extra hires due to inaccurate hour data.
• Management time spent chasing discrepancies instead of value-adding work.

Administrative burden

• Investigating anomalies and correcting timesheets.
• Reconciling payroll and fielding disputes—slowing close cycles.

Legal & ethical implications

(General information only—this is not legal advice.)

United Kingdom

• Employment law: Falsifying timesheets can be gross misconduct under the contract and disciplinary policy. Repayments for genuine overpayments may be deducted in line with the Employment Rights Act 1996, but handle reasonably (e.g., agreed repayment plans).
• Criminal risk: Serious, deliberate falsification could amount to fraud (e.g., under the Fraud Act 2006) if there’s dishonest false representation to obtain pay.

United States

• FLSA pay rules: Employers must pay for all hours actually worked. If time was not worked (i.e., proven padding), it needn’t be paid—but be careful with deductions and state laws. Many states restrict post-payment deductions; use corrective payrolls and document thoroughly.
• Rounding: Permitted only if neutral and consistent over time.
• Discipline vs. pay: You can discipline for falsification, but don’t withhold pay for hours actually worked.

Ethical & cultural impact

• Erodes trust and fairness; demotivates honest team members.
• Creates conflict between managers and staff; harms retention.

Detection & indicators of padding hours

Audit patterns & anomalies

• Clock-ins/outs overly clustered at exact quarters (e.g., 09:00, 17:00).
• Unusual overtime patterns, especially on lightly supervised shifts.
• Near-identical punches among multiple employees (possible buddy punching).

Behavioural warning signs

• Regular late arrivals/early departures without explanation.
• Defensiveness or avoidance when queried about records.
• Drop in accountability or rising dissatisfaction.

Manual vs. digital tracking

Digital systems (biometric, GPS/geofencing, mobile apps) surface discrepancies fast and reduce manipulation compared to paper or spreadsheets.

Privacy note: Biometric data is highly regulated. In the UK/EU, it’s special-category data under GDPR; you’ll need a lawful basis, DPIA, and strict safeguards. In the US, states like Illinois (BIPA) require informed consent and specific notices. GPS tracking also demands clear, transparent policies.

Prevention strategies & best practices

1) Move to digital time tracking

• Accurate clock-in/out with mobile, kiosk, or biometric verification (where lawful).
• Break logging to capture paid/unpaid time correctly.
• Geo-fencing for field staff; tamper-resistant audit trails.

2) Clear policy & training

• Define acceptable rounding (if any), break rules, and overtime approvals.
• Explicitly prohibit buddy punching and timesheet falsification, with graduated consequences.
• Train employees and managers regularly; share quick guides/FAQs.

3) Payroll integration & alerts

• Real-time flags for missing punches and sudden overtime spikes.
• Automated reconciliation to cut admin time and reduce errors.
• Exception workflows for quick manager review and sign-off.

4) Design for fairness

• Fix root causes (unclear break rules, unrealistic schedules, poor staffing) that nudge people into padding.
• Use neutral rounding rules (or none) and apply them consistently.
• Recognise teams that model accurate, honest timekeeping.

HR-led response & disciplinary approaches

How to handle suspected padding

• Meet privately and invite the employee’s explanation.
• Gather clear evidence (system logs, CCTV, access records) and keep an audit trail.
• Apply your policy consistently across similar cases.

Progressive discipline (illustrative)

Build a culture of integrity

• Talk openly about expectations and ethics; model accuracy from the top.
• Reward reliable timekeeping and transparent corrections.
• Use data to improve staffing/scheduling, not just to punish.

Prevent padding hours with Shiftbase

Time tracking, employee scheduling, and absence management in Shiftbase make padded hours harder and honest mistakes easier to catch—thanks to real-time alerts, audit trails, and seamless payroll exports.

See how much admin time and payroll leakage you can save—try Shiftbase free for 14 days.

Employee scheduling and Time-tracking software!

• Easy Employee scheduling
• Clear time-tracking
• Simple absence management

Try for free Request a demo