Padding hours

Padding hours means recording more time on a timesheet than was actually worked, a few minutes at a time, so the extra minutes are paid.

Written by: Rinaily BonifacioUpdated on:

Padding hours means recording more time on a timesheet than was actually worked. In practice it is a clock-in at 08:52 for a 09:00 shift, a lunch break that ran to 45 minutes but went down as 30, or a week of hours written up on Friday afternoon from memory. Each entry is a few minutes off, always in the same direction, and the minutes are paid.

What is padding hours?

Padding hours, also called time padding or timesheet padding, is adding minutes or hours to a timesheet that were not spent working, so that the employee is paid for them. The time is real time on the premises or on the clock, but no work was done in it, or the work never happened at all. It is a form of time theft, and usually the most common one, because each entry is small enough to pass as rounding.

Outside the workplace the phrase has two other meanings. In project planning, padding time is a buffer added to an estimate so the plan survives delays, which is good practice. In law firms and agencies, padding means billing a client for more hours than a task took. On a timesheet for shift work it means the first: minutes on the clock that were not worked.

Common methods of padding hours

Most padding comes from a handful of habits, and each one leaves its own trace in the data:

Method

What happens

Where it shows

Early clock-in

Clocks in 10 minutes before the shift, then has coffee

Clock-in well before the scheduled start, every day

Late clock-out

Finishes at 17:00, clocks out at 17:12 after a chat

Clock-out after the scheduled end with nothing to close down

Rounding in one direction

Writes 09:00 for 09:07 and 17:00 for 16:53

Paper or typed times that are always whole quarters

Breaks not deducted

A 45-minute lunch recorded as 30, or not recorded at all

Unpaid break shorter than the schedule allows, or missing

Filling in from memory

The week is written up on Friday

The same start and end times on five days in a row

Clocking in for someone else

A colleague clocks in for someone who is running late

Two clock-ins seconds apart on one device

The last one has its own name, buddy punching, because it involves two people. The others are done alone and are easier to explain away, which is why they last longer.

Padding or unpaid work?

Not every extra minute is padding. A chef who stays 20 minutes to finish the prep, or a cashier who counts the till after the doors close, is working, and that time has to be paid. Under the US Fair Labor Standards Act, work that the employer did not ask for but allowed to happen is still working time (29 CFR 785.11). So the question for each extra minute is what happened in it. If the employee was working, the record is right and the schedule may be wrong. If they were not, it is padding.

Rounding sits in between. Rounding to the nearest 5, 10 or 15 minutes is accepted in the US if, over time, it does not leave employees under-paid (29 CFR 785.48(b)). An employee who always rounds in their own favour is padding; an employer who always rounds against the employee is under-paying. The page on time clock rounding covers where that line sits.

Impact on business operations & payroll

The cost of padding hours is easy to underestimate because no single entry is worth arguing about. Take a shop with 15 staff on a 5-day week. Say each of them clocks in 6 minutes early and out 4 minutes late without working, and the hourly rate is £12:

  • 10 minutes a shift × 5 shifts = 50 minutes per person per week

  • 50 minutes × 15 people = 12.5 hours a week

  • 12.5 hours × 50 working weeks = 625 hours a year

  • 625 hours × £12 = £7,500 in wages, before employer's National Insurance and pension

That is a part-timer on 12.5 hours a week who never works a shift. When those minutes push someone past their contract hours, they turn into overtime that nobody approved, paid at a higher rate. And the wage bill is only half of it. Labour reports that count padded hours show shifts as busier than they were, so the next schedule gets more cover than the work needs.

Payroll padding: when the payroll itself is inflated

Payroll padding is the wider term. It covers any way of making the payroll pay more than it should: padded hours, but also ghost employees (people on the payroll who don't work there, or who left months ago), pay rates raised without approval, and overtime or bonuses that were never earned. The difference is who does it. Padded hours are usually the employee's doing. Ghost employees and changed rates need someone with access to the payroll, which is why the controls are different.

For padded hours, the control is comparing recorded hours with the schedule. For the rest, it is separating duties: the person who adds employees and changes pay rates is not the person who approves the payroll, and someone checks every month that each name on the payroll also appears on the schedule. A paid employee who never works a shift is the clearest sign of a ghost.

Detection & indicators of padding hours

Padding is found by comparing three things: what was scheduled, what was clocked, and what was worked. Where the first two differ, a manager who was there can usually say which one was right.

Pattern

Check

Innocent explanation to rule out

Clock-ins 5-15 minutes before every shift

Compare with the scheduled start, per employee, over a month

A handover or set-up task that should be on the schedule

Breaks shorter than the policy allows

Compare recorded breaks with the break rule and the floor

A break cut short because the shop was busy

Hand-written times that are always whole quarters

Ask for the clocked times or the till log

A paper form that only offers quarters

Hours edited after the shift

Look at who changed what, and when

A forgotten clock-out being corrected

Two clock-ins seconds apart on one device

Check the schedule and the camera at the door

Two people who arrived together

One late clock-out says nothing. The same employee 10 minutes over on 18 of 20 shifts says a lot, and so does a team where everyone is over on the shifts one particular manager runs.

This is general information, not legal advice. The rules differ by country and, in the US, by state.

United States

Employers have to pay for every hour actually worked, including work they allowed but did not ask for (29 CFR 785.11). Time on the clock without work does not have to be paid: employees who come in before their start time or stay after their finishing time and do no work in that time need not be paid for it, and their early or late punches may be disregarded (29 CFR 785.48(a)). The same section asks employers to discourage large gaps between clock records and hours worked, because they make the records doubtful. In practice that means a clear rule about when to clock in, applied the same way to everyone. Whether pay already made for padded hours can be taken back depends on state law, so take advice before deducting anything. Whether padding can be charged as a crime is covered on the page about time card fraud.

United Kingdom

The protection against unauthorised deductions from wages (section 13 of the Employment Rights Act 1996) does not apply when an employer recovers an overpayment of wages (section 14(1)(a)). Wages paid for padded hours can therefore be taken back, though a sudden deduction from someone's pay still damages trust more than an agreed repayment plan. Padding is a disciplinary matter under the employer's own policy, and deliberate, dishonest padding can be fraud by false representation under section 2 of the Fraud Act 2006, which explicitly covers a false statement submitted to a system or device, such as a time clock.

Ethics on the shop floor

Colleagues usually know who pads their hours. When nothing happens, honest staff see that the rule is for them only, and that costs more over time than the minutes do.

How to handle suspected padding

Start with the data and a conversation. Pull a month of clocked hours next to the schedule, mark the shifts that are off, and ask the employee what happened on those days. Often there is an answer: a task nobody scheduled, a broken clock, an unclear rule about when to clock in. If there isn't, write down what was found, what the employee said and what was agreed.

What follows depends on your policy and on the size of it. A first case is usually a conversation and a written rule. Repeated padding after that conversation is a written warning, often headed as a time padding violation. Deliberate, large-scale padding, or padding combined with buddy punching, can be gross misconduct. Apply the same steps to everyone, because an employee disciplined for what a colleague got away with has a fair complaint.

Prevention strategies & best practices

Padding shrinks when the record is made at the moment of work and checked against the plan:

  • Clock in and out instead of filling in a timesheet afterwards. A clocked time can be checked; a remembered one can't.

  • Set a rule for early arrival: clocking in more than a few minutes before the shift does not start paid time unless a manager asks for it.

  • Record breaks by clocking out and back in, or apply the scheduled break and let the employee report a shorter one.

  • Round to the nearest interval or not at all, never always in one direction.

  • Approve timesheets before they go to payroll, and close the period afterwards so hours can't be changed later.

  • Put tasks that start early or finish late, such as opening up or cashing up, on the schedule so they are paid and visible.

On a building site or a cleaning round, where crews work away from a manager, the weekly paper timesheet is where padding hides. Clocking in at the start of the job on a phone, and approving the hours the same week, takes most of the room away.

In Shiftbase, time and attendance runs on the same schedule the hours are checked against. Employees clock in on the app or on the Kiosk, which runs in the browser on a PC or tablet. You can set Shiftbase to use the scheduled start time when someone clocks in within a set window before the shift, and the scheduled end time when they clock out shortly after it, so early arrivals and slow goodbyes don't turn into paid minutes. Rounding is set separately for clock-in and clock-out. Clocked hours can be approved automatically only when they match the schedule, so every shift that doesn't match waits as pending for a manager. Try Shiftbase free for 14 days with your own team's hours.

Frequently asked questions

Time padding on a timesheet means recording more time than was worked, so the extra minutes are paid. In project planning the same words mean adding a buffer to an estimate, and in law firms billing a client for more hours than a task took.

Payroll padding is inflating the payroll so it pays out more than it should. It includes padded hours on timesheets, ghost employees who don't work for the company, pay rates raised without approval and overtime or bonuses that were never earned.

Padding hours is a breach of the employment contract and the employer's timekeeping policy almost everywhere, and deliberate, dishonest padding can be a crime. In the UK it can count as fraud by false representation under the Fraud Act 2006; in the US it depends on the state and the amount, as explained under time card fraud.

Clocking in early is padding hours only when the employee does no work in that time and is paid for it. Under US federal rules, early punches without work may be disregarded for pay. If the employee does start working early and the employer allows it, that time is working time and has to be paid.

Employees stop padding their hours when the hours are clocked at the moment of work, compared with the schedule and approved before payroll. Add a clear rule about when to clock in, record breaks, round neutrally or not at all, and talk to the employee before anything else when the numbers don't match.

A time padding violation is a breach of company timekeeping rules by recording time that was not worked. The term is used in disciplinary notices and warning letters, and the consequence depends on the company's policy: from a written warning for a first case to dismissal for deliberate or repeated padding.

An employer in the UK can recover wages paid for padded hours, because the Employment Rights Act 1996 lets an employer deduct an overpayment of wages (section 14(1)(a)). In the US it depends on state law, so take advice before making any deduction from pay.

Rinaily Bonifacio
Rinaily BonifacioSenior Content Marketer

Rinaily writes for Shiftbase about HR, scheduling and building teams people actually want to work in. She turns the messy reality of workforce planning into practical advice you can put to work today.

See all terms