How to Manage Time Off Requests Fairly: A Simple Guide

time off request policy, request time, time off request form, employee requests, how much advance notice, handle time off requests, handling time off requests, request forms, employees submit requests, paid time, submit time off requests, paid vacation time, time off request procedure, advance notice, vacation time, submit requests,

In this detailed guide we take a closer look at ways to effectively manage time off request and provide you with tips on creating a time off request policy that satisfies everyone.

What are time off requests?

Time off requests are formal ways for employees to ask their employers for permission to be absent from work for a certain period. They are a crucial part of maintaining a healthy work-life balance and ensuring smooth operations within a company.

Benefits of time off requests

  • For Employees: It provides a clear and documented method for requesting leave, reducing stress and confusion.
  • For Employers: It helps streamline the process of managing staff absence and ensures they can plan for coverage.

Types of time off requests:

  • Paid Time Off (PTO): Employees accrue hours or days off that they can use for vacations, personal days, or sick leave.
  • Unpaid Time Off: When PTO is exhausted or not offered, employees may request unpaid leave for various reasons.

The time off request process:

  • Employees submit a formal request, often through a designated system or by contacting their manager.
  • The request specifies the type of leave, dates, and reason (optional, depending on company policy).
  • Managers review the request considering factors like workload and staffing coverage before approval.

Communicate your time-off policies at the start

It is important to communicate the policy for employee time off to all new hires regardless of which option you choose. Failure to do so may result in confusion and uncertainty among employees regarding the regulations and consequences for taking time off.

  • Certain employees tend to request time off frequently without any specific reason, which can create resentment among their co-workers due to the lack of boundaries.

  • There are employees who may hesitate to ask for something because they are not sure about what is acceptable. This can result in feelings of frustration and burnout.

If your business is under a union contract, there may be time-off policies you have to follow. In such cases, you are obligated to comply with these policies. You want to consider adding more flexibility to your time-off policies, which should involve giving managers the discretion to handle unforeseeable situations.

Include your policies in the employee handbook and ensure it is readily available for employees to refer to for any queries. Additionally, discuss the policies during the hiring interviews to ensure that everyone is on the same page from the start.

Create a system for tracking employee time off requests

When it comes to managing employee time-off requests, having an organized system in place is key. This should include records of who requested vacation days and when they will take them.

You can use software or HR tools for tracking employees' vacation days or create a simple spreadsheet.

This will ensure that requests are handled in an efficient and organized manner.

Creating an online form for your time off requests system can also help streamline the process. The form should include information such as name, dates requested, approved/denied status, and other related details.

You should have a process in place to review time-off requests. This will help ensure that no request goes unnoticed and each one is handled according to your standards.

Set a deadline for requests

Each industry experiences high-intensity seasons where taking too much time off can negatively impact the business. Retail, specifically, requires all employees on board during the winter holidays.

If there are certain occasions when you need to limit the time-off requests, you can consider setting a specific deadline or time frame for submitting the requests. The purpose of this is to prevent individuals from requesting for the following year when some of the employees who will work during that period have not been hired yet.

It's important to inform all employees at once if you decide on a deadline for time-off requests. This is necessary since it's possible to receive more requests than can be accommodated, and you'll have to establish a fair procedure for deciding whose requests can be approved. The methods rely on the principle of first come, first served, which is only fair if all individuals are equally informed that they can submit a request.

The most frequently used methods by employers to manage time off during holidays are: first-come, first-served and seniority.

  • First come, first served: To ensure fairness in granting time off, the employee who submits their request first is given priority. Therefore, it is important to inform all employees about the deadline for requesting time off ahead of time. Being flexible is crucial so that the same employees do not end up working during holidays just because they missed the deadline by a day.

  • Seniority: This is most suitable for situations where there are conflicting time-off requests that are equally valid for all other reasons.

  • This method gives priority to those who have higher seniority and ensures that experienced employees are not taken advantage of.

  • Ultimately, having a fair system in place is essential for managing time-off requests efficiently and fairly.

Please refrain from using arbitrary managerial discretion as it appears to show favoritism, mainly if you do not provide a specific reason for granting time off to some employees and denying it to others.

Avoid relying solely on first-come, first-served or seniority-based systems for time off requests. This can make new employees feel demotivated and that they are unlikely to ever have their preferred time off since they haven't been in the organization long enough.

It's important to keep in mind that younger employees tend to switch jobs more frequently. Seniority-based methods for granting time off may not be fair to them and could even cause them to leave your company sooner.

Use employee rewards during peak times

Choosing a reward-based approach is preferable over a punitive one. Imposing too many rules can lead individuals to feel suppressed. To handle peak times, such as holidays and weekends, that usually face a lot of time-off requests, it is beneficial to incentivize employees who are willing to work during those periods.

As an example, if you have an employee who is available to work every weekend in December, you could offer them the perk of having priority in selecting the first two weekends off in January or guaranteeing that they won't get stuck with any closing shifts during those weekends.

While other types of rewards can be effective, providing time-off bonuses is a practical solution for addressing time-off concerns. It's worth noting that there may be employees who don't desire time off, but for the majority of employees, this type of incentive is beneficial.

Create a rotating schedule for all employees

One of the top ten complaints that employees have, according to HR Solutions, Inc., a management consulting firm specializing in employee engagement surveys, is favoritism. This issue can manifest in various ways, including how time off is managed.

Useful Read: Navigating HR Consulting: A Comprehensive Guide

It can be easy to unintentionally show favoritism to certain employees, such as the one who consistently requests weekends off in the summer or the one who frequently cites family emergencies. This can result in discrepancies in time off between these employees and those who are quieter and more reserved. Remember that the squeaky wheel often gets the oil, so it's important to be mindful of how time off is distributed among all employees.

A rotating time-off schedule can be used in this scenario.

To ensure fairness when managing time-off requests, it is wise to rotate schedules for employees. This is especially important regarding holidays and weekends. Employees tend to remember if they were constantly assigned to work on holidays or weekend shifts, or if they worked on a specific holiday in the past. By implementing a rotating schedule, you can prevent these situations from occurring.

Track previous requests

To effectively keep track of employees' time-off requests, make sure to document the date of the request, the reason for the request, and the exact dates the employee will be taking off. This will help ensure accurate record-keeping.

Keeping track of employee time-off requests, although it may seem burdensome, can help you identify any repetitive issues and give you a stronger basis for declining a time-off request from an employee who frequently asks for the same reasons.

You can determine if there are employees who ask for time off less frequently based on how you monitor the requests. These employees may also warrant time off but they might not be self-assured enough to make the request themselves. If you can identify this pattern, you can ensure that all employees are given a fair chance at getting their desired time off.

For flexibility, allow employees to trade shifts or days

Legitimate emergencies can happen unexpectedly, and it's important to provide your employees with time off when necessary.

However, it can be challenging if you have a set rotating schedule or if the employee has already used up their allowed time-off requests.

Allowing employees to exchange shifts or agree on different schedules amongst themselves reduces the perception that you are demonstrating bias.

Using the app, employees can request shift swaps, which are then forwarded to the manager for approval. This is particularly useful in situations where an employee calls in sick with short notice.

Please make sure to communicate with an employee who frequently works for others and confirm that they are doing it willingly without feeling pressured.

It's important to address any power struggles or bullying issues as some employees may not feel comfortable declining requests to cover someone else's shift.

Fairly managing time-off requests involves a balance of following policies, being flexible for emergencies, and avoiding favoritism.

Giving employees the option to volunteer to cover a shift empowers them and ensures they don't feel completely dependent on their manager's decisions.

Manage leave and absence with ease!

Manage leave and absence with ease!

  • Automatic accrual of vacation hours
  • Request leave easily
  • Leave registrations visible in the planning
Try for free Request a demo

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, managing time-off requests fairly means being aware of the policy and implementing a rotating schedule while also giving employees options to trade shifts or request days off. Streamlining this process with a digital system can provide additional benefits such as accuracy and fairness while reducing the workload of managers.

To ensure all employees are treated equally, it’s important to take a proactive approach and understand their individual needs. With the right strategy, you can manage time-off requests without bias and with confidence.

Streamline time off requests with Shiftbase

Managing time off requests can be a hassle, especially with traditional methods. Shiftbase, your one-stop shop for workforce management, simplifies this process with its absence management feature. Employees can easily submit requests through our user-friendly interface, while managers can review and approve them within the platform.

This eliminates the need for paper trails and ensures clear communication throughout the process.

Stop wasting time on administrative tasks and focus on what matters most. Try Shiftbase for free for 14 days and see how easy absence management can be! Sign up for your free trial today!

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Managers should be familiar with the company policy and consider all requests fairly. They should also consider allowing employees to trade shifts or take other days off if needed. Additionally, digital solutions can simplify the process and ensure accuracy and fairness in managing employee time-off requests.

  • Using a digital system to manage employee time off requests can provide numerous benefits such as accuracy, fairness, and reduced administrative workload. Additionally, it promotes openness and equality since all requests are saved in one place for easy retrieval. It also decreases the possibility of prejudice or favoritism.

  • To be proactive means taking an active approach and understanding the individual needs of employees. This includes being aware of the policy, implementing rotating schedules, and providing options such as shift swaps or days off. It also involves using digital solutions to streamline the time-off request process. By taking a proactive approach, managers can ensure all employees are treated fairly and with confidence.

  • The steps for managing time-off requests fairly include understanding company policy, implementing a rotating schedule, offering shift swaps and days off as options, and utilizing digital solutions to streamline the task. Managers should take a proactive approach by understanding the unique needs of each individual employee.

Absence Management
Topic: Time off
Rinaily Bonifacio

Written by:

Rinaily Bonifacio

Rinaily is a renowned expert in the field of human resources with years of industry experience. With a passion for writing high-quality HR content, Rinaily brings a unique perspective to the challenges and opportunities of the modern workplace. As an experienced HR professional and content writer, She has contributed to leading publications in the field of HR.


Please note that the information on our website is intended for general informational purposes and not as binding advice. The information on our website cannot be considered a substitute for legal and binding advice for any specific situation. While we strive to provide up-to-date and accurate information, we do not guarantee the accuracy, completeness and timeliness of the information on our website for any purpose. We are not liable for any damage or loss arising from the use of the information on our website.